Overall rating


by 7 people

I bought 4 lip liners. 2 is impossible to use!

Jul 16, 2016

I bought 4 lip liners. 2 of them is impossible to sharpen. The wood of the penn hurts my lips. Not what I expect of an YSL product.

I'm Glad I Tried These

Jun 4, 2014

I have these in four colors: Fuschia, a wearable, not too bright or dark berry, as opposed to hot pink. Gorgeous. Natural , which is like your own lips amped up a bit. Not as neutral or dusky as the name suggests. This one is my HG. Cognac, another HG, is a carmelly orangish light brown, stunning. And lastly, Rose, a lighter than your lips delicate peachy-pink. I use this one rarely, as it is too light for me.

I love how these go on. Not too creamy, not too dry. They stay put nicely and are just SO user friendly that I hope they never discontinue. I enjoy the colors and will continue to buy more. I think I'll try Wine next.

Good enough

May 28, 2014

It's one of the best things I tried ever. You should try it.

Please don't discontinue cognac lipliner!

Oct 24, 2015

Read the comments above. It is everyone's favorite. Perfect in the fall and winter with so many of your lip colors. I tried to buy it today at Nordstrom's and they said they thought you must be discontinuing it because they can't order it. Please tell me this is not so!!!

My favorite lip liner ever!

Jul 6, 2016

I used your #1 lip liner for many years. It is the perfect color and texture and lasts almost all day. I have looked and looked and feel very frustrated that I cannot find the precise color or texture in any other brand, nor do they last. Please start making this beautiful, perfect color again!!!

I won't use anything else

Aug 3, 2016

I've used this for years and YSL is the only way to go...perfect texture for a lip liner, goes on smooth and stays in place. Beautiful!

My favorite lip liner

Jun 14, 2017

This is the only liner that I buy! It has a smooth easy application!