Question should i use this pencil for my water line?

• Answer I did put on my waterline it stays somewhat but the best one that stays on your waterline is Milani Liquif'eyeliner its perfect on the waterline and its cheaper! by Diana M 05/09/12
• Answer I would like to help, but do not know what you mean by "waterline". I use the pencil dry during the day, but at night I pass it quickly through a light stream of water to give darker and longer lasting definition. You will love it....i can't do without it! by yvonne l 05/09/12
• Answer I would like to help, but do not know what you mean by "waterline" by yvonne l 05/09/12
• Answer the colors of these pencils are beautiful and unique. but! sad to say, they smudge and chunk up on the eyelids :( by Pamela R 05/09/12

Question I'm really considering buying this pencil for the first time and can't decide between the purple or the aquamarine. Is the aquamarine a dark navy or more teal? I have a caramel complexion but don't want a very bright color.

• Answer Thank you Valerie! That makes me really happy. I ordered the simmering burgundy for now but will certainly purchase the ultramarine next. I thought it might be more versatile given my skin tone. by Cynthia R 04/17/12
• Answer Hi! The ultramarine is a great color. It is more of a dark navy. Not bright at all!! by valerie c 04/17/12
• Answer Thank you Laurie! That's very helpful. I was hoping it was a dark blue. Cynthia by Cynthia R 04/16/12
• Answer Cynthia, I have been wearing the aquamarine for 6 months. It's a dark blue and really stays in place. I love it! Laurie by Laurie F 04/16/12

Question What are the ingredients?

Question where are the eyeliners made ?

• Answer These are made in Germany!! by valerie c 03/11/12
• Answer I don't remember. But I trust their products and I have never been disappiointed with any of them. Most of them seemed to have been made in France . by daisy m 03/07/12

Question Emily blunt said she bought an eye pencil called long lasting eye pencil #2. It looks like a beautiful brown. I have a problem as my eyes run in the mirning from allergies. Will this pencil act like a waterproof one or could i use the waterproof in the same manner to smudge with?

• Answer I was very disappointed in this pencil. I also have issues with eyes that won't stay dry. The color beaded up on my eyelids and fell into my eyes even if I let it dry by keeping my eyes closed for a couple minutes. by Arlene W 02/29/12
• Answer I've only used the Waterproof pencil, but I find that once it's on, it stays on. Its very soft and smudgable before it sets, so I don't think watery eyes should be a problem. I tend to rub my eyes a lot, and I've never had a problem with mine. by Abigail C 02/28/12
• Answer I also have allergies and watery eyes, but my eye makeup stays put thanks to my favorite eyeliner. YSL waterproof eye pencil is the best on the market!!! I apply my eyeliner in the morning and it lasts all day until I remove it at night. The texture is so creamy and the pigment is strong. You can smudge this eyeliner and it still looks amazing. I highly recommend this eyeliner to anyone who's in search of a waterproof pencil. by LORIE L 02/28/12
• Answer You can smudge it, I find if I don't go over it with a brush it flakes in my eye and causes vision problems. Color is very intense and pencil is easy to apply. by sandy k 02/28/12
• Answer I love this liner...it goes on like silk and dries very quickly. I really dont smudge my liner so cant say it would work like that. You should try it! by VICKY H 02/28/12
• Answer From my experience, if you eyes are running, just as long as the skin on the eye is dry when you put on the eyeliner, the liner should not budge when your eyes run thereafter. It takes only a minute or so for your liner to set and once it's set, you're generally protected from runny eyes or moisture to the eye that will ruin your make up, giving you that raccoon eye look. The only problem I had with this eyeliner, which is absolutely beautiful and the brown is gorgeous, is that the liner itself is extremely soft so you have to be very gentle when applying so as not to break the point. Also, be very careful when sharpening the pencil because if you're not, you will keep sharpening, loosing way too much product. This eyeliner is too expensive to waste like that. I think you should be OK with this eyeliner even with runny eyes. May I make a suggestion? Get this liner at Sephora, use it for a few days and if not satisfied, you can return it to sephora for a full refund with the receipt even if you have used the product. I have all the YSL eyeliner pencils and I particularly love the 2 Greens and the purple. But every one is gorgeous and works as they say it does. Take a chance and purchase it. I think you'll be very happy. by Diane K 02/28/12

ad in magazine

because my other eye liners always smear out.

love it

Good color

I FIND THAT IT LASTS THROUGHOUT THE DAY.

I love it

wanted something that didn't rub off.

I have yet to find an eye pencil-liner that does not smudge or give me raccoon eyes. I have NEVER purchased an eye pencil at this price, so I hope this is the one!

Bought this in the teal color. Loved it, but had to return because it was fogging up my contact lenses. No one else had this issue that I've hear of, so great buy if you don't wear lenses.

I read somewhere that this was a great eye pencil. I chose this color because I seemed pretty universal....